Custom as a Source of Law in Jurisprudence
In jurisprudence, Custom is considered one of the oldest and most influential sources of law.
1. Definition and Nature
A custom is a rule of conduct which the governed observe spontaneously and not in pursuance of a law settled by a political superior.
Ancient (Immemorial): Practiced for a very long time.
Continuous: Followed without interruption.
Reasonable: It should not be against justice, equity, or good conscience.
Certain: The practice must be clear and not ambiguous.
Compulsory: Observed as a right, not as a choice.
Read Also: CONCEPT, NATURE, AND SCOPE OF JURISPRUDENCE
2. Types of Customs
Customs are generally divided into two main categories:
(i) Legal Customs: These operate as a binding rule of law independently of any agreement.
- General Custom: Prevails throughout the country.
- Local Custom: Applies only to a specific locality or district.
(ii) Conventional Customs (Usages): These are binding only because they have been incorporated into a contract between parties (common in commercial law).
3. Customs in Different Religious Laws
Custom plays a pivotal role in personal laws. Most religious legal systems started as customary practices that were later codified or interpreted by scholars.
A. Hindu Law
In Hindu Law, custom is known as 'Achara.' It is considered superior to written texts in many instances.
Historical View: The Smritis acknowledge that custom can override sacred law. The Privy Council famously held: "Under the Hindu system of law, clear proof of usage will outweigh the written text of the law."
Current Status: Under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, certain customs are protected (e.g., marriage ceremonies or prohibited degrees of relationship can be bypassed if a valid custom exists).
Condition: A Hindu custom must not be "opposed to public policy" (e.g., Sati was a custom but was abolished because it was immoral).
B. Islamic Law (Sharia)
In Islamic jurisprudence, custom is known as 'Urf' or 'Aadat.'
Validation: While the Quran and Sunnah are primary, 'Urf' is a valid secondary source if it does not contradict the primary texts.
Application: It is often used to interpret contracts or determine the amount of Mahr (dower) when it is not specified.
Restriction: If a local custom (Urf) conflicts with a clear Quranic injunction, the custom is void.
C. Christian Law
Christian law is largely governed by Canon Law and statutory law (like the Indian Christian Marriage Act).
Role of Custom: In the early Church, customs helped shape the liturgy and administrative rules.
Legal Force: In modern legal systems, Christian customs are less dominant than statutes, but they still influence traditions regarding burials, church management, and certain social rites.
D. Parsi and Jewish Law
Parsi Law: Their customs (rooted in Zoroastrianism) regarding inheritance and marriage were largely codified into the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act.
Jewish Law: Known as 'Minhag.' There is a famous Jewish legal maxim: "Custom overrides Law." This shows the deep respect for community practices in Jewish legal thought.
4. Why Custom is a Source of Law
Reflects Public Opinion: It shows what the people actually want and follow.
Ease of Compliance: Since people already follow it, the law becomes easier to enforce.
Stability: It provides a sense of continuity and tradition in society.
5. Modern View (Analytical vs. Historical School)
Historical School (Savigny): Believes custom is the main source of law.
Law grows with the people (Volksgeist). Analytical School (Austin): Believes custom is not law until it is recognized by the Sovereign or a Court.
Read Also: Schools of Jurisprudence
Conclusion
In conclusion, Custom serves as the foundational bedrock of legal systems worldwide. While modern states prioritize Legislation (laws made by Parliament) and Precedents (judgments by Courts), the importance of custom remains undiminished, especially in the realm of personal and religious laws.
The transition from "habit" to "custom" and finally to "law" represents the evolution of human civilization. In a diverse country like India, customs act as a bridge between ancient traditions and modern legal requirements. However, as society progresses, courts continue to filter customs—keeping those that are beneficial and striking down those that are "unreasonable" or "opposed to public policy." Ultimately, a custom is valid only as long as it serves the interest of justice and the welfare of the community.
Comments 0